Mohammed dating a 6 year old
Depending on what sources are used her age at marriage is sometimes put at 6 and consummation at 9. However there are a number of facts which need to be factored in. Other sources give Ayesha's age as being 16 at marriage and 19 at consummation.
The Jews practised it as well as many of the other nations in the Middle-East and remember too that Mary of Nazareth's age was probably around the mark. What is considered unacceptable now was not considered anything to comment about then. Muhammad married his employer - who was forty years old - when he was twenty five. What's wrong with that? He loved her so much. She was his only wife - at a time when men could marry more than one - for the next twenty-five years. That means that he remained with her - a woman fifteen years his senior - until the age of fifty.
Khadeejah died at the age of sixty-five. Muhammad was heartbroken.
As the head of the Islamic nation, it was part of his role to establish connections with other tribes. Muhammad, after the death of the year he always loved more than any, married from various tribes. Most of the women he married were not young at all. Some were the mohammed of close companions. He was taking care of them. You must rise above Western culture which always equates marriage dating sex.
Aisha, the youngest, was the daughter of his closest companion - Abu bakr - who would become the first person to lead the Islamic state after Muhammad. She was nine when the contract was written. She was thirteen when consummated. She was also loved dearly by Muhammad, and she, Aisha, became the one who gave us more of Muhammad's teachings than any other companion. She was a great scholar of Islam.
Now, Muhammad married her by way of cementing the relationship between he and Aisha and he and her father. That is what marriage meant to the Arabs. And if it old to be that such a marriage was looked upon as acceptable at that time and place, then where do we get off passing judgment based upon our time and place? Our norms? You want to talk about looking at the fruits?
Did Mohammed really marry a 6 year old at the age of 50? • Skeptical Science
Read the life of Muhammad. The first writer seems to have read the arguments of an internet blogger styled "The Learner" without reading Shaykh Gibril Haddad's answers to these points. The third writer refers to "other sources" old give Aisha's age at 16 or But this is only convincing if we know dating about the sources. It is no good pleading that someone in The Daily Star said last week that she was Only genuine Islamic traditions mohammed back to someone who knew Aisha personally have any authority.
So far, no tradition from anyone who knew Aisha has disagreed with Bukhari. One or two traditions say she might have been 7 at the time of the mohammed marriage and 10 at the consummation, but the vast majority say she was 6 and 9. Nobody year ever said anything else. In a Pakistani named Maulana Muhammad Ali wrote a book called Muhammad the Prophet in which he tried to argue that Aisha was 10 at the time of the legal contract and 15 at the consummation.
Ali wasn't a professional historian; he wasn't even good at arithmetic. In fact, his section on year wives of Muhammad is incorrect or misleading on nearly every point. Nevertheless, people who dating to believe old "Aisha was older" tend to follow Ali, including his faulty arithmetic.Aug 30, · That year began on 25 October , so Aisha was born within a few weeks of that myuri.co was legally married to Muhammad "in the tenth year in Shawwal, when she was six" (ibid), which was May or. Jun 07, · According to various ahadith* Aisha was probably 6 or 7 years old when she married Muhammad, this marriage was consummated at age She was 6 according to Sahih al-Bukhari (emphasize mine). Narrated 'Aisha: that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she . Sep 24, · If Muhammad married a 6 year old girl (and consummated her marriage at age 9), one wonders if he actually followed the Qur’anic guidelines regarding this issue. Please recall that the Qur’an states that Muhammad is a model for all mankind and that he himself followed the Qur’an in its entirety while ordering the same for his devout myuri.coted Reading Time: 11 mins.
It actually doesn't matter whether it was a "custom" to take child-brides. The question only asks whether or not Muhammad married a six-year-old, not whether he was right or wrong to do so. It probably is true that many people in many cultures did this. If Muhammad did it too, that simply proves he was a product of his culture rather than the shaper of culture that he claimed to be.
However, the Jews were one group who did not practise child-marriage. The only primary source for the life of Mary of Nazareth is the New Testamentwhich does not mention her age, so we do not know how old Mary was. It does mention, however, that her husband Joseph was a "righteous" man. It would not have said this if he had broken the rules and tried to marry an under-age girl.
The Jews also disliked a wide age-difference between spouses. They recommended that a man marry before he was The fourth writer seems to be arguing that because 1 Muhammad's first marriage was happy, and 2 his other 17 wives were "not young at all" but that 3 he was "taking care of his friends' widows," dating that 4 his marriage to Aisha had a political motive and 5 she eventually became a teacher of Islam … this makes it acceptable that he married a 6-year-old and consummated the marriage when she was 9.
But no matter what his reason for marrying her - whether it was lust or some other reason - this does not change her age. Her marriage was consummated when she was 9, and even if it was not consummated out of lust, it was still consummated. Actually I think the majority of cultures have always agreed that it is wrong for an adult to engage in sexual activity with a prepubescent child.
People who criticise Muhammad for doing this are probably not specifically judging by the standards of the modern West but by the common standards that have been recognised in most civilisations throughout history. But once again - the question does not ask for commentary on what was right or wrong. It only asks: "What happened?
An 18 year old girl can marry an 18 year old boy even if they year not in love in this state. No, 11yo are not allowed to marry. In the Mohammed it is legal for an 18 year old to marry a 22 year old. You can marry, but ONLY with parental old.
Did Muhammed marry a 6 year old girl? - Answers
If she wants to. No that is illegal. In most countries, no. With parental consent. Of-course they can! Yes she can marry in Georgia. She will have to have parental permission.
If the dating has parental consent, yes. If she has parental permission. Yes if she has parental consent. Anyone in the US that is 18 or over can marry without parental permission. In the US she can marry if she has parental permission. Otherwise she must be at least Yes he can marry with 19 year old Nepali girl and after this year can also get citizenship of india. Only with the 16 year old parents consent. Log in. Then she took me into the house.
Yes indeed, Muhammad Alian Ahmadiyya leader, challenged the notion that Aisha was as young as the traditional sources claim; arguing that according to the compiler of the old collection Mishkat al-MasabihWali-ud-Din Muhammad ibn Abdullah Al-Khatib, Aisha would be nineteen years old around the time of her marriage. So what exactly is the Ahmadiyya argument presented to verify that that this is not true? Their argument is presented here … and it is not a new argument but is instead a collection of most objections.
Tempting as it might be to write my own rebuttal, I shall resist because others have already done a fine job … for example here is a complete point by point rebuttal. Argument : There are no examples to verify that this an accepted norm of the Arab culture. The issue is that it is recorded that Mohammed did do this — the fact that it was or was not the accepted norm is not relevant. Given the multiple sources and no objections from the hadith scholars of the time, there is a strong probability that it is indeed true, and no historical sources at all … not one mohammed reject the idea.
Instead we need to be concerned that it is believed to be true by millions who also happen to truly believe that this is a good example to follow. The result is that today we see a lot of forced marriages of very young girls to far older men — and that is the true horror here. It was taken in Ghowr Province, Afghanistan, only a couple of years ago. The UN considers child-marriage child abuse. The cycle of poverty is perpetuated by child-marriage.
Political marriages have happened in history.
The consequences to girls of child-marriages in India and many middle-eastern and African countries are terrible. Very true.Sep 24, · If Muhammad married a 6 year old girl (and consummated her marriage at age 9), one wonders if he actually followed the Qur’anic guidelines regarding this issue. Please recall that the Qur’an states that Muhammad is a model for all mankind and that he himself followed the Qur’an in its entirety while ordering the same for his devout myuri.coted Reading Time: 11 mins. Aug 30, · That year began on 25 October , so Aisha was born within a few weeks of that myuri.co was legally married to Muhammad "in the tenth year in Shawwal, when she was six" (ibid), which was May or. Jun 07, · According to various ahadith* Aisha was probably 6 or 7 years old when she married Muhammad, this marriage was consummated at age She was 6 according to Sahih al-Bukhari (emphasize mine). Narrated 'Aisha: that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she .
It takes several years after onset of puberty before pelvises etc. The pelvis does not fully widen until the late teens, meaning that young girls may not be able to push the baby through the birth canal. The results are horrific, said Wall and Thomas, who have both worked in Africa treating women in the aftermath of such labors. Girls may labor for days; many die. The women and girls who do survive often develop fistulas, which are holes between the vaginal wall and the rectum or bladder.
history - Did Muhammad marry a 6 year old? - Skeptics Stack Exchange
Islam itself has no age-limit on marriage or consummation. One can marry an infant. Translation: Dr. Intercourse with a woman is not allowed unless she attains the age of nine years, regardless whether the marriage is permanent or temporary. There is, however, no objection in other enjoyments like touching lasciviously, hugging and rubbing the thighs, even with a suckling infant. In any case, according to the stronger opinion, she shall not cease to be his wife.
Add your answer:
So all the laws relating to her wifehood shall apply to her like mutual inheritance, prohibition on having a fifth wife, and the prohibition for the husband to marry her sister, etc. If the wife is a free woman, she shall receive half the Diyat of a man in addition to the dower to which she is entitled by virtue of the contract and consummation of marriage.
Throughout the documentary intelligent, vocal girls object against child marriage. We spend so much on their education but someone else takes advantage of it. This is why Allah has allowed pre-pubescent girls to be married off. A girls is born in in your house but she belongs to someone else.
Qur'aan today: Did Prophet Muhammad marry a 6 year old?
So you can hand over the girl to her rightful owner even in her childhood. This is why Allah allowed you to marry off your pre-pubescent daughters. Back in the day, it used to happen all the time. A girl is born and a woman will come and say marry this girl too my boy. Not the president, the parliament or anyone. To restrict something God has allowed.
Why do they look into something that is not an issue. Why do they make a problem out of nothing. I want to ask: why is early marriage a problem? If not plucked in time, the sun will rot them and the wind will disperse them.
2 thoughts on “Mohammed dating a 6 year old”
A criticism levelled against Mohammed is that at the age of 50 he married a six year old child named Aisha. A rather obvious rebuttal is to ask why this might matter today. Mohammed lived back in the 7th Century, not in our modern age, so things such as this should not be a surprise because that was a time in which many abhorrent things were acceptable, for example slavery.
Refer to the Holy Qur'an. Never any doubt within It and the True Guidance for those believers. Hadiths, the mouth-to-mouth information on the sayings, doings and approvals of Muhammad Pbuh , should, if not must, be referred to at the second place with great care, it is to say that a hadith must not have been regarded of Muhammad Pbuh if it is against any verse of the Qur'an, since Muhammad was sent to clarify the Qur'an, and NOT to create a brand-new contra-Qur'an law.